About Us

Hathaway Mill Antiques is an antique lover’s heaven, offering a very unique shopping experience. Sun streams in through huge windows, 16-foot ceilings add a sense of grandeur,  exposed brick – all add to a wonderful browsing experience. The multi-dealer antique emporium boasts over 75 quality displays, making it one of the largest antique destinations in Northern New England. It truly is worth a trip from anywhere. Our friendly and very knowledgeable staff is here to ensure every visit you make is a pleasant one. We love answering questions and talking “antiques”!

Our History


Deborah J. Stufflebeam - Manager

Deborah J. Stufflebeam is the manager of Cabot Mill Antiques. She is the mother of six and grandmother of twelve. The family lovingly refers to themselves as the Brady Bunch.
Deborah has worn many professional hats beginning her work career in the 1980’s as a spinner in the Carlton Woolen Mills in Winthrop Maine.

Read more

Samantha L. Stufflebeam - Assistant Manager

Samantha L. Stufflebeam is Cabot Mill Antiques Assistant Manager. Her work experience and love for antiques started well before she arrived at Cabot Mill in 2007. She began her passion with Deborah Stufflebeam (the Manager of Cabot Mill and also Samantha’s mother) as a child age 7 traveling from shop to shop in central Maine looking for those lost treasures and shiny trinkets.

Read more

Nancy Jean Gatti - Sales Associate

Nancy is the matriarch of Cabot Mill Antiques or more lovingly referred to as the “Queen Mum.” In 1996 Cabot Mill Antiques was established and Nancy has been here since its inception.
Nancy is a graduate of Newton High School in Newton, Massachusetts. After graduating Nancy married the love of her life Anthony Gatti Jr in 1962. Nancy and her husband moved to Maine in 1964 and started their family.

Read more

Donna Tompkins - Sales Associate

Donna has been on staff at Cabot Mill Antiques for over six years.
Donna attended Massena Central High in Massena New York where she graduated and then attended Central City Business Institute where she received her business degree. Donna married her husband Joel during that time and they lived in Syracuse New York until 1995.

Read more

Paula Coffin - Sales Associate

After retiring from her job of 20 years at Bath Iron Works, Paula’s quest for the perfect part-time job lead her to Cabot Mill Antiques. She thoroughly enjoys coming to work and absolutely loves what she is doing.
Paula has always dabbled in antiques and appreciates the quality and beauty in them. If she finds a piece of antique furniture that is neglected, she refinishes it and finds it a good home. Her passion and knowledge for antiques, especially jewelry, aids her aptly assisting customers.

Read more